If you’ve had a piercing before that didn’t quite work out. Or maybe you removed it years ago. You might be wondering: Can I get pierced again in the same spot? The short answer is: sometimes! But when it comes to piercing through scar tissue, there are some important things to consider.

Whether the original piercing was rejected, irritated, or simply retired, getting a new one in the same area isn’t always as simple as starting fresh.

What Is Scar Tissue, Exactly?

Scar tissue forms as part of the body’s natural healing response. When a piercing is removed or rejected, your body begins to rebuild the tissue that was disrupted. Sometimes this results in soft, barely noticeable skin; other times, it can create a firmer, raised area known as hypertrophic scarring—or in some cases, a keloid (a type of overgrown scar).

This scarred area doesn’t behave quite the same as untouched skin. It can be thicker, more fibrous, and sometimes less elastic, which may affect how it heals if pierced again.

Can You Re-Pierce Through Scar Tissue?

Often, yes—but it depends on a few key factors:

  • How much scar tissue is present
    A small amount of scar tissue may not pose much of a problem, but thick or raised scarring might need to be worked around—or avoided entirely.
  • How the original piercing healed (or didn’t)
    If your original piercing was removed due to trauma, rejection, or persistent infection, we’ll want to carefully assess whether the area is suitable for re-piercing.
  • Your anatomy
    Scar tissue can sometimes alter the natural shape or flexibility of an area, especially with ear cartilage, navels, or nipples. We’ll evaluate if it’s possible to place a new piercing safely and comfortably.

The Importance of an In-Person Consultation

I always recommend an in-person consult if you’re considering re-piercing a site with existing scar tissue. During your visit, I’ll:

  • Visually inspect and examine the area
  • Discuss your piercing history and any issues you experienced
  • Offer realistic feedback on placement, healing, and expectations

In some cases, we may suggest moving the piercing slightly to avoid the thickest areas of scar tissue or recommend alternative placements entirely.

Healing Expectations

Healing a piercing through scar tissue can take a little longer than a fresh spot. Scarred areas have altered blood flow and structure, which means they may be more prone to:

  • Swelling
  • Delayed healing
  • Irritation bumps or redness
  • Slight asymmetry during healing

That’s why following a strict aftercare routine is even more important in these cases. We’ll walk you through the best practices and recommend a proper check-in schedule to monitor your progress.

When It’s Not a Good Idea

In rare cases, we may advise against re-piercing altogether. Especially if:

  • The scar tissue is too dense or unstable
  • You’ve developed keloids in the past
  • The area has significant anatomical changes or thinning
  • There’s a high likelihood of repeat rejection or trauma

We’ll always be honest about your options, and if needed, help you explore alternative placements or styles that still align with your goals.

The Bottom Line

Piercing through scar tissue isn’t a one-size-fits-all situation. I treat every body as unique and every piercing as a collaboration between artist and client. If you’re wondering whether you can repierce a retired hole or give an old favorite a second chance, I’m here to help you make an informed and safe decision.

Book a consult with me to get a professional evaluation. I’ll work with you to create a piercing plan that’s realistic, respectful of your body, and totally stunning.